Why music asset valuations are running wild and the impact on deal making.
The deal that should have worked
Earlier this year I worked on the valuation of a well-known artist’s catalog. Years of consistent releases, a loyal audience, steady streaming. Growing genre globally, on all major streaming platforms. On paper, exactly what labels and investors say they want.
Catalogs are priced as a multiple: how many years of today’s royalties a buyer pays up front. Comparable catalogs were selling for somewhere in the low-to-mid teens. To earn a 15% annual return — the bar many investors set — we could offer meaningfully less: nearer ten years of income than fifteen.
Nothing was wrong with the music. The gap was between what the market expects a seller to be paid and what a buyer can pay and still earn its return. That gap is now the defining feature of this market.
The squeeze: The price of music, and the price of money
Spotify for Artists, a product I helped scale while at Spotify, moved the mark for the industry, permanently. All of a sudden anyone could plot listening behaviors tied to tracks and artists. And, the capital followed.
There has never been more capital chasing music. BMG/Concord, Firebird, Duetti – to name a few. Every known PE firm has a fairly large bet in this space.
All that money has kept prices high. Proven catalogs (music more than ten years old) have traded at roughly 18 to 20 times annual income every year since 2020. The swings are in younger music: catalogs aged five to ten years peaked around 20x in the 2021 boom, dropped into the low teens in 2024 and recovered to the high teens in 2025.
Here’s why that matters. Pay 19 times a year’s royalties and those royalties pay you back about 5% a year. Valuations at today’s prices assume buyers will accept single-digit returns, and those returns keep getting thinner. A buyer who needs a 15% return has three ways to get there: borrow, bet on selling later at a higher price, or pay less than the seller expects.
Sellers feel that last one. In Duetti and Billboard’s H2 2026 Music Finance Index, 74% of dealmakers named price expectations as the biggest barrier to closing deals. And borrowing is getting more expensive, not cheaper: the Fed raised rates to 3.75–4% in September, with further increases expected.
You can’t just buy the copyright
In a market like this, the return isn’t in the purchase. It’s in what you do after. A catalog bought and left alone will decay. A catalog that’s worked can grow.
Working a dance catalog takes real operating effort, and most of it depends on the scene around the music:
- Remixes and edits. New versions and extended mixes for today’s DJs keep a record in rotation.
- DJ support. Getting tracks back into sets, and making sure they’re identified when played, turns club plays into streams.
- Live moments. Tour dates, festival sets and anniversaries are when listeners go back to the catalog.
- Nostalgia cycles. Music comes back in waves. Being ready when an era returns is worth more than any playlist pitch.
- Money that goes missing. Performance and neighboring-rights income from clubs, radio and DJ sets often goes uncollected. Clean metadata and registrations bring it home.
This is hard. It takes people, systems and relationships that most financial buyers don’t have. And it’s the part of the deal that a spreadsheet can’t price.
In the deal I worked on, the plan to work the catalog — its first real marketing in years, active sync pitching, recovering missed royalties — was what made it exciting. But it was the upside we could hope for, not something we could pay for up front.
The alternative: license, don’t sell
There’s another way to fund an artist’s future: a long-term license instead of a buyout. The partner gets the right to exploit and administer the catalog for a fixed term. The artist keeps ownership of the masters, and the rights come home when the term ends.
This changes the incentives. A licensee earns by growing the catalog during the term, so the model rewards working the copyright, not just holding it. And for the artist, the upside after the term — and every creative decision along the way — stays theirs.
The model also fits how dance music was built. Many producers started on their own labels, released their own records and have owned their masters from day one. In this scene independence isn’t a negotiating position; it’s the culture. A license lets an artist fund what’s next without giving that up — and keeps the person whose name is on the DJ sets and festival bills involved in growing the catalog.
That’s the model we believe in at UnitedMasters: artists should own their work, and capital should be a partner in building its value, not a replacement for the artist as owner.
The trade-off: can you bear less money now?
A license pays less up front than a sale. That’s the honest cost of keeping your masters, and artists should hear it plainly.
A sale pays the most up front, but the buyer owns the masters forever, keeps the upside and makes the creative calls, and its incentive is simply to hold the asset. A license pays less now, but the artist keeps the masters, the upside returns to them after the term, creative control stays with them, and the partner only earns by growing the catalog while the term lasts.
A sale can be the right call — for an estate, for a retirement, for an artist who wants certainty. But for an artist still building a career, the bigger check often buys less than it seems. The real question is whether you can live with less today in exchange for owning your work tomorrow.
So who should own the future of music?
The people who make it — with capital as a partner, not a landlord. Money flowing into music is a good thing. But the returns will go to whoever does the work of growing a catalog, not whoever writes the biggest check.
That catalog taught me something the model couldn’t. An artist’s life’s work is more than numbers. It’s years of decisions, risks and meaning — and a spreadsheet can only ever price it on the past.
The best deals line up the two: capital that funds the artist’s next chapter, and an artist who still owns the story.